The esteemed 19th-century Russian mathematician Sofya Kovalevskaya, a trailblazer for gender equality in her field, characterized mathematics as “a science which requires a great amount of imagination.”

Given that imagination is a universal human attribute, it is my conviction that everyone possesses the innate capacity to appreciate the subject of mathematics. Far from being solely about calculation, it represents a sophisticated fusion of logical deduction, critical reasoning, the identification of patterns, and innovative thought processes.

Furthermore, a growing body of evidence from scientific inquiry, including research from sources like ScienceDaily and PubMed Central, consistently highlights the cognitive advantages and developmental benefits derived from engaging with challenging puzzles.

The learning theory proposed by Canadian psychologist Donald Hebb, often encapsulated as “when neurons fire together, they wire together,” serves as a foundational principle, notably guiding the architecture of contemporary artificial intelligence systems, particularly in the training of extensive neural networks. This process facilitates the formation of novel neural pathways, thereby contributing to the establishment and sustenance of robust cognitive faculties.

Moreover, the practice of mathematics frequently unfolds as a collaborative undertaking, offering a rewarding avenue for enjoyment and personal accomplishment when individuals unite their efforts to tackle complex problems.

This leads us to the collection of festive-themed enigmas presented herewith, designed to be approachable by an entire household. No specialized mathematical instruction or intricate formulae are prerequisite for their resolution.

It is my fervent hope that these challenges provide moments of serene contemplation amidst the holiday festivities. The solutions will be disseminated on Monday, December 29, with a direct link incorporated here. Best of luck to all participants!

Festive Mathematical Conundrums

Riddle 1: Presented with nine outwardly identical gold coins, you are informed that one is counterfeit and possesses less mass than the genuine articles. Your sole instrument for verification is a vintage balance scale, capable of comparing the weights of two distinct groups of items.

Inquiry: What is the absolute minimum number of weighing operations required to definitively identify the fraudulent coin?


A Christmas pie with a slice removed.
(rimmabondarenko/Canva)

Riddle 2: Imagine yourself transported to a bygone era, tasked with preparing a grand Christmas feast. Your specific duty involves baking the festive pie, yet the kitchen is devoid of timekeeping devices, rendering even rudimentary clocks and mobile phones unavailable.

The only available implements are two hourglasses: one calibrated for precisely four minutes, and the other for exactly seven minutes. The formidable head chef has decreed that the pie must be baked for a duration of precisely ten minutes, no more, no less.

Inquiry: How can you accurately measure a ten-minute interval under these constraints, thereby avoiding the chef’s displeasure?


Riddle 3: Having successfully overseen the preparation of the Christmas pie, you are now entrusted with the crucial task of portioning the mulled wine, presently stored in two ten-litre casks.

The chef provides you with two empty vessels: a five-litre bottle and a four-litre bottle. His explicit instruction is to dispense precisely three litres of wine into each of these containers, without any wastage.

Inquiry: What sequence of actions will enable you to achieve the precise three-litre measure in both bottles?


Riddle 4: For the purposes of this exercise, let us posit an extended “12 Days of Christmas” that spans one hundred days. On each successive day, denoted as the n-th day, you are presented with a monetary gift equivalent to £n, commencing with £1 on the inaugural day and concluding with £100 on the final day. Consequently, the total sum received represents an overwhelming quantity of funds, impractical to tally manually.

Inquiry: Is there a method to ascertain the aggregate sum of money received without undertaking the tedious process of summing each of the hundred individual amounts?

(A conceptual antecedent to this problem was historically posed to the renowned German mathematician and astronomer Carl Friedrich Gauss.)


Riddle 5: Behold a Christmas-themed numerical progression. The initial six terms in this sequence are observed as: 9, 11, 10, 12, 9, 5. (Please note: some renditions of this puzzle list 11 as the fifth term.)

Inquiry: What numerical value constitutes the subsequent term in this established sequence?

A child in festive Christmas attire opening advent calendar compartments.
(pixelshot/Canva)

Riddle 6: Examine the subsequent compilation of assertions:

  • Precisely one statement within this ensemble of declarations is untrue.
  • Exactly two statements within this collection are false.
  • Precisely three statements from this compilation are erroneous; and so forth, up to:
  • Exactly 99 declarations within this series are inaccurate.
  • Exactly 100 statements presented here are untrue.

Inquiry: Which solitary statement amidst these one hundred declarations holds the distinction of being verifiably true?


Riddle 7: You find yourself in a confined space alongside two individuals, Arthur and Bob, both possessing impeccably rational minds. Each of you is adorned with a Christmas hat, which is either crimson or emerald in hue. No participant can ascertain the color of their own headwear, but everyone can observe the hats worn by the other two.

You observe that both Arthur’s and Bob’s hats are crimson. Subsequently, all participants are apprised that at least one of the hats is crimson. Arthur then vocalizes, “I am unable to determine the color of my hat.” Following this, Bob states, “I too am uncertain of my hat’s color.”

Inquiry: Based on this exchange and your observations, can you definitively deduce the color of your own Christmas hat?


Riddle 8: Beneath your Christmas tree lie three distinct boxes. One contains a pair of diminutive presents, another houses a duo of coal pieces, and the third holds a single small present alongside a piece of coal. Each box bears a label purportedly indicating its contents; however, these labels have been inadvertently interchanged, resulting in every box being incorrectly marked.

You are granted permission to inspect the contents of only one box.

Inquiry: Which box should you select to open, thereby enabling you to subsequently reposition the labels so that each accurately reflects its respective contents?


Riddle 9: In the moments preceding the Christmas banquet, a mischievous character named Jack enters the kitchen, where a one-litre carafe of orange nectar and an identical one-litre vessel of apple elixir are present. He proceeds to transfer a tablespoonful of orange juice into the apple juice container, thoroughly agitating the mixture to ensure uniform distribution.

However, a similarly impish individual, Jill, witnesses this action. She then retrieves a tablespoonful of the resultant liquid from the apple juice bottle and introduces it into the orange juice container.

Inquiry: Is the quantity of orange juice now present in the apple juice bottle greater than, or less than, the amount of apple juice now residing within the orange juice bottle?


Riddle 10: In the utopian locale of Santa’s residence, all currency notes feature depictions of either Santa Claus or Mrs. Claus on one face, and either a gift or a reindeer on the opposite side. A young apprentice elf arranges four such notes on a surface, revealing the following imagery:

Santa | Mrs. Claus | Present | Reindeer

At this juncture, an elder, more sagacious elf imparts a guiding principle: “Should Santa be visible on one side of a note, it is imperative that a present be depicted on the reverse.”

Inquiry: Which specific notes must the junior elf invert to definitively validate the correctness of the elder elf’s assertion?

Children clad in Christmas attire examining a scroll.
(pixelshot/Canva)

Supplementary Conundrum

Should a festive tie-breaking challenge be required, consider this query that necessitates a degree of algebraic manipulation (and the application of the formula “velocity = distance / time”). It might be tempting to conclude this problem is unsolvable due to the absence of a specified distance; however, the inherent elegance of algebra promises a definitive resolution.

Santa embarks on his annual journey, traversing from Greenland to the North Pole at a constant velocity of 30 miles per hour. He then commences his immediate return voyage from the North Pole back to Greenland, maintaining a velocity of 40 miles per hour.

Tiebreaker Inquiry: What is the calculated average velocity for Santa’s complete round trip?

(A non-seasonal variant of this problem was previously presented by the American physicist Julius Sumner-Miller.)

The Conversation