Earth’s Thermostat Broken: Warming Surge Doubles in 20 Years

8 Min Read

How is the progression of climate change quantified? One method involves meticulously documenting temperature fluctuations across various locales over extended durations. While this approach yields valuable data, inherent natural variability can obscure the detection of more profound, long-term trajectories.

However, an alternative methodology offers a remarkably lucid perspective on prevailing conditions: by monitoring the quantum of thermal energy entering Earth’s atmosphere versus the amount dissipating outwards. This is referred to as Earth’s energy budget, and it is currently profoundly destabilized.

Our recent investigation revealed that this disequilibrium has more than doubled over the past two decades. Independent researchers have arrived at concordant findings. This imbalance now significantly exceeds the projections generated by climate modeling simulations.

NASA accumulates vital long-term observations of our evolving planet from its vantage point in space. (NASA, CC BY-NC-ND)

During the mid-2000s, the energy deficit registered approximately 0.6 watts per square meter (W/m2) on average. In more recent years, this average has climbed to around 1.3 W/m2. This signifies a quadrupling in the rate at which thermal energy is being sequestered in proximity to the planet’s surface.

These discoveries indicate a distinct possibility of climate change accelerating in the forthcoming years. Compounding this concern, this disquieting imbalance is manifesting even as funding uncertainties in the United States jeopardize our capacity for precisely tracking these thermal energy flows.

Thermal Input and Output Dynamics

Earth’s energy budget operates analogously to a personal ledger, where income and expenditures are meticulously tracked. A reduction in spending leads to an accumulation of financial reserves. In this planetary context, energy serves as the fundamental medium of exchange.

The sustenance of life on Earth hinges upon a delicate equilibrium between incoming solar radiation and outgoing thermal energy. This balance is currently faltering.

Solar radiation impinges upon Earth, inducing warming. The atmospheric constituents, specifically greenhouse gases, retain a portion of this incoming thermal energy.

However, the combustion of fossil fuels, encompassing coal, petroleum, and natural gas, has introduced an excess of over two trillion tons of carbon dioxide and other heat-trapping gases into the atmosphere. These substances augment the retention of thermal energy, impeding its egress.

A portion of this surplus thermal energy contributes to terrestrial warming or the ablation of ice formations, encompassing sea ice, glaciers, and ice sheets. Nevertheless, this represents a marginal proportion. A substantial 90% has been absorbed by the oceans, attributable to their considerable thermal capacitance.

Earth naturally dissipates thermal energy through several mechanisms. One primary avenue involves the reflection of incident solar radiation back into space by clouds, snow, and ice formations. Additionally, infrared radiation is emitted outwards towards space.

From the inception of human civilization until approximately a century ago, the average surface temperature hovered around 14°C. The cumulative energy imbalance has now elevated average temperatures by 1.3 to 1.5°C.

Icebergs and a sunset
Reflective ice and clouds serve to deflect thermal energy back into the cosmos. As the planet warms, the majority of trapped heat is assimilated by the oceans, though some contributes to ice melt and the heating of terrestrial and atmospheric domains. (narloch-liberra/Canva)

Observational Data Exceeding Predictive Models

Scientists diligently monitor the energy budget through dual principal methods.

Firstly, direct quantification of incoming solar radiation and outgoing thermal energy is achieved through the deployment of highly sensitive radiometers aboard monitoring satellites. This comprehensive dataset, along with its predecessors, extends back to the late 1980s.

Secondly, the accumulation of thermal energy within oceanic and atmospheric systems is precisely gauged through systematic temperature measurements. Thousands of autonomous robotic floats have been instrumental in surveying oceanic temperatures globally since the 1990s.

Both observational techniques unequivocally demonstrate a rapid amplification of the energy imbalance.

The doubling of the energy imbalance has proven surprising, as sophisticated climate models, which are currently in widespread use, largely failed to anticipate such a pronounced and accelerated shift.

Consistently, these predictive simulations indicate less than half of the magnitude of change that is being observed in real-world conditions.

Rationale for the Accelerated Change

A comprehensive explanation remains elusive at this juncture. However, emerging research points towards alterations in cloud cover as a significant contributing factor.

Clouds exert an overall cooling influence. Nevertheless, the expanse covered by highly reflective, white clouds has diminished, concurrently with an expansion in the area occupied by more convoluted, less reflective cloud formations.

The precise drivers of these cloud pattern transformations are not yet fully understood. A potential contributing element might be the unintended ramifications of successful initiatives to reduce sulfur content in marine fuels, which commenced in 2020. Prior to this, the combustion of higher-sulfur fuels may have imparted a brighter, more reflective characteristic to clouds.

However, the accelerating trend in the energy budget imbalance predates this specific regulatory change.

dense clouds
Dense formations of white clouds exhibit maximum heat reflectivity. However, the extent of these cloud blankets is currently shrinking. (Alex_Schmidt/Canva)

Intrinsic fluctuations within the Earth’s climatic system, such as the Pacific Decadal Oscillation, may also exert influence. Finally, and perhaps most concerningly, these observed cloud modifications could represent an emergent pattern driven by global warming itself, thereby constituting a positive feedback loop amplifying climate change.

Implications of the Findings

These findings strongly suggest that recent exceptionally warm years are not isolated occurrences but may portend an intensification of warming trends over the ensuing decade or longer.

This scenario predicts an increased propensity for more severe climatic impacts, ranging from extreme heatwaves, prolonged droughts, and intense precipitation events on land, to more formidable and persistent marine heatwaves.

This energy imbalance might precipitate more detrimental long-term consequences. Emerging research indicates that only those climate models incorporating a heightened “climate sensitivity” parameter are approximating real-world observational data.

Consequently, these models project more severe warming trajectories beyond the next few decades under scenarios where greenhouse gas emissions are not curtailed with urgency.

It remains premature to definitively ascertain whether other contributing factors are in play. Sufficient time has not yet elapsed to conclusively establish whether we are on a path toward a high-sensitivity climate trajectory.

Our Orbital Sentinel System

The definitive solution has been recognized for a considerable period: cessation of the pervasive combustion of fossil fuels and the progressive phasing out of anthropogenic activities contributing to emissions, such as widespread deforestation.

The maintenance of precise, long-term observational records is indispensable for the timely detection of unforeseen environmental shifts.

Satellites, in particular, function as our paramount early “`

Share This Article